Customer reviews of the Nedis USB 3.0 to IDE/SATA Adapter for HDD/SSD 2.5"/3.5

39€⁹⁵

Global rating

7/10

based on 13 reviews Editorial and moderation guide

• 54%

  7 reviews
• 8%

  1 review
• 15%

  2 reviews
• 8%

  1 review
• 15%

  2 reviews

• by boby

  Posted on 6 Aug 2024

  Bought on 11 Jan 2020 from LDLC

  Number of reviews: 7 Average rating: 9
  good product

  this product is functional and practical, and perfectly meets my expectations.
  It correctly recovers data from my HDDs.

  Review automatically translated

  +
• by GuyD

  Posted on 3 Sep 2023

  Bought on 30 Aug 2023 from LDLC

  Number of reviews: 1 Average rating: 2
  Does not detect discs correctly

  Tested on 2 3.5" SATA drives (1TB and 3TB), 3 PCs (Windows 10 and 11) and 2 USB ports (2.0 and 3.0). The enclosure is detected by all the PCs (in any case in USB 3.0) but it's impossible to access the disks: in 1 case the enclosure lights up the "SATA" LED (HDD 3TB) and in the other it doesn't (1TB).
  I haven't found out why, I'm going to ask the after-sales service but, given the other comments, I've taken an ill-considered risk!

  Review automatically translated

  +
• by Jean-Charles R

  Posted on 17 Dec 2022

  Bought on 14 Dec 2022 from LDLC

  Number of reviews: 1 Average rating: 2
  No need

  I was looking to transfer several old hard drives or SSDs to a new computer and purchased this . I tested two 3.5" SATA hard drives and two 2.5" SATA SSDs, all three in perfect working order, but none of them were recognised by the adapter...
  I then tested an old IDE drive. Miracle, it works, even if I'm not interested...
  So very disappointed with this purchase!

  Review automatically translated

  +
• by Nicolas L

  Posted on 18 Sep 2022

  Bought on 6 Nov 2021 from LDLC

  Number of reviews: 3 Average rating: 9
  Moderately satisfied

  The USB3 connection does not work with IDE disks, you must be in USB2 for the disk to be recognised.
  For SATA disks, no problem with USB3.
  
  The only drawback is that the IDE and Sata ports are too high up so that the adapter-disk assembly, once plugged in, lies flat when in use: the whole thing lies at an angle with a voltage on the pins.
  A switch would have been handy too.

  Review automatically translated

  +
• by Laurent M

  Posted on 26 Jun 2022

  Bought on 28 Jul 2021 from LDLC

  Number of reviews: 16 Average rating: 9
  very practical

  functional and very practical to hot mount a SATA disk (and even old PATA disks, so doubly interesting)
  based on an Innostor IS611 chipset, perfectly Linux compatible (I use Fedora)
  the only problem is that I can't get access to the SMART data of the disk via this interface, hence the explanation for the missing star (info I manage to get when the disk is directly connected in SATA)

  Review automatically translated

  +
• by Frédéric D

  Posted on 10 Jun 2022

  Bought on 13 May 2022 from LDLC

  Number of reviews: 15 Average rating: 10
  very good product, makes the TAF

  I have been using this product for some time now and it has been a great success.
  Recovers data from old HDDs (IDE or SATA) efficiently.

  Review automatically translated

  +
• by Serge G

  Posted on 23 Jan 2022

  Bought on 17 Jan 2022 from LDLC

  Number of reviews: 1 Average rating: 4
  Unreliable product.

  Tested on three hard disks of an old PC from which I wanted to recover data, only one is recognized with this device.

  Review automatically translated

  +
• by PascalT

  Posted on 10 Dec 2021

  Bought on 12 Nov 2021 from LDLC

  Number of reviews: 2 Average rating: 10
  Simplicity

  Fits my needs perfectly............................................................................................................................................

  Review automatically translated

  +
• by FrancisD

  Posted on 8 Jan 2021

  Bought on 30 Dec 2020 from LDLC

  Number of reviews: 1 Average rating: 10
  It is a good device

  This adapter works very well, it allowed me to recover very old files.
  If on the same IDE hard drive one day it works fine but the next day it doesn't work anymore, it's not the adapter that's at fault but most probably bad contacts or dry soldering of the hard drive. I had the problem and solved it with the "first maintenance": a fiddle here and there!

  Review automatically translated

  +
• by stéphanie B

  Posted on 3 Jun 2020

  Bought on 4 May 2020 from LDLC

  Number of reviews: 17 Average rating: 9
  Not really a stable product

  The product works quite well on a usb2 port, but in usb3 I am obliged to restart the pc so that the detection is done and I have regular disconnection of the product.
  I'm not sure if it's a good idea to use it on a usb2 port, but it's not a good idea to use it on a usb3 port, because it's not a good idea to use it on a usb2 port.
  I'm not sure if it's a good idea to have a driver for it, but I'm not sure if it's a good idea to have a driver for it, because it's not a good idea to have a driver for it, because it's not a good idea to have a driver for it.
  I have an ide cd drive that works perfectly but only in usb2.
  I have tested 2 old IDE hdd's that work perfectly, but are not recognized with this product.
  I am not really satisfied.

  Review automatically translated

  1
• by Michel Terrier

  Posted on 1 Apr 2020

  Bought on 3 Mar 2020 from LDLC

  Number of reviews: 6 Average rating: 8
  ergonomics

  Works fine, but not very practical from an ergonomic point of view. The one I bought from LDLC maybe 10 or 15 years ago, in USB 2 ? was bigger but more practical. But it broke down, it had had its day.
  I would like to remind you that this device works correctly and in USB 3.

  Review automatically translated

  +
• by Pierre W

  Posted on 15 Jan 2020

  Bought on 17 Dec 2019 from LDLC

  Number of reviews: 4 Average rating: 10
  Excellent product

  This is a well-designed connector, made in China and made of durable materials, which allows you to retrieve data even from old IDE HDDs, direct transfer, in USB 3.
  Ideal for those who give a hand, friendly or professional :-)

  Review automatically translated

  +
• by LionelP

  Posted on 27 Jul 2019

  Bought on 25 Jun 2019 from LDLC

  Number of reviews: 1 Average rating: 10
  Indispensable!

  I am the proud owner of an old device of the same kind, but which gave up the ghost after many years of service, I am very satisfied with this new model. It's very useful for recovering data when an old computer goes up in smoke, without having to fiddle with installing the old hard drive in the new machine (and even then, when it's possible). There, you can find everything, as if you were plugging in a USB key. The speed is variable depending on the age of the disk, but there are no problems, even with old IDE standards.

  Review automatically translated

  +